Eventide H90 MIDI PC Change and Bypass at the same time

Home Forums Products Stompboxes Eventide H90 MIDI PC Change and Bypass at the same time

Viewing 16 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #187986
      stroboscapes
      Participant

        I’m trying to use my Boss MS3 to change the Program on the H90 and bypass it at the same time.

        I have the MIDI Bypass CC# set to 0. When I set the configuration like attached, it does indeed bypass the H90 with a value of 0 and activate it with a value of 127.

        However, if I send a PC# along with it, then it doesn’t bypass. In the example attached if I set the PC to anything other than “OFF” it ignores the Bypass CC and turns the H90 into active.

        I tried the same with an H9 and it works as expected, the program changes and the bypass CC correctly sets the bypass state. How can I do this with an H90?

        Attachments:
        You must be logged in to view attached files.
      • #187988
        stroboscapes
        Participant

          Looking at the log files I’m assuming the MIDI bypass messages are being ignored:

          ‼️ [TRPCMessageBroker.h:147].midiReceived > Ignoring inbound message ID:0x1d due to pendingResponseID:0x1b
          ‼️ [TRPCMessageBroker.h:147].midiReceived > Ignoring inbound message ID:0x19 due to pendingResponseID:0x1b

          Any information what this means?

        • #187989
          brock
          Participant

            As an educated guess, the H90 Program is still loading via the PC when the CC message arrives, a scant few milliseconds later (if that).  Another speculation: the H9 – even with an older processor – is loading less than half of data that an H90 Program contains.

            I suppose it’s possible to hold incoming MIDI messages in a buffer, delaying it long enough to slide into the MIDI stream shortly after the last command has completed.  As a serial protocol, you’re bound to run into some limitations with MIDI vs. the power of modern processing.

            I haven’t checked back your use case with either an H9 or H90.  If I need a Program (or one of its Presets) to load bypassed, I re-save it with Bypass engaged.  Then use an Act/Byp command as needed.

          • #187990
            stroboscapes
            Participant

              That’s really a bother and not something I’d expect from such a high price point. I’ve noticed I’m not the only one with this use case and having to load everything disengaged and engaging it from another preset means I lose the flexibility of having one preset for each program but I would need to have 4 to cover each use case of A/B being bypassed.

              I guess I’ll be returning the H90 and keeping the H9 since at it’s current state the H90 is unusable for my purposes.

            • #187999
              tbskoglund
              Keymaster
              Eventide Staff

                Hello,

                We are aware that there is an issue with this use case and are working on a solution. Previous versions of the firmware should allow you to use the simultaneous PC+CC messages, or if you use Program level active/bypass mappings (not global active/bypass mappings) then that should work as well.

                I’d be happy to help you with this further if you email support@eventideaudio.com.

                • #188004
                  mcvittym
                  Participant

                    I note that ‘previous versions of the firmware should allow you to use the simultaneous PC+CC messages‘.  Is there a previous version of the firmware that will do this that does not also have the issue where presets would load with the wrong delay time (AUD-74364)?

                • #188001
                  stroboscapes
                  Participant

                    Just to comment that the Program level active/bypass does not work when sending PC+CC messages. I have tried it several times. No CC messages get recognised after sending the PC. I will contact support.

                    Apparently it should work with firmware 1.8.6. I’ll try downgrading it and confirm.

                  • #188003
                    mcvittym
                    Participant

                      I logged exactly this problem with Eventide support on 24 January. It’s a pretty big deal for me, also.

                    • #188006
                      stroboscapes
                      Participant

                        I can confirm that the MIDI switching works with 1.8.6. At least from initial testing. I’ll have to check if it causes any audible difference or lag when using it in a signal chain.

                        • #188023
                          mcvittym
                          Participant

                            Which version of H90 control are you using with H90 firmware 1.8.6?

                          • #188133
                            stroboscapes
                            Participant

                              The latest I could find from the site

                          • #188231
                            kturner
                            Participant

                              I also logged this issue, last year. It makes the H90 somewhat unusable and I am back to using my Strymon pedals because they work properly with MIDI.

                               

                              • #188235
                                tbskoglund
                                Keymaster
                                Eventide Staff

                                  Sorry to hear this has stopped you from being able to use the H90. To clarify, after looking into this issue further we have confirmed that a simultaneous MIDI PC+CC will work correctly on the previous firmware version 1.8.6. We are looking into a fix for this for a future update. If you’d like to downgrade your pedal, please email support@eventide.com and I can help you do that.

                              • #188925
                                stroboscapes
                                Participant

                                  Just an update: H90 edit now doesn’t work. It only tells me that a software update for the H90 is required and won’t let me into the preset editor. So basically I have to chose if I can use the pedal the way I intended, or if I want to use the editor.

                                  This makes it somewhat useless, doesn’t it?

                                • #188926
                                  stroboscapes
                                  Participant

                                    I understand that you need version 1.7.11 of the H90 edit to use the previous firmware, not the latest one, but I can’t download the previous version of the editor.

                                  • #188956
                                    stroboscapes
                                    Participant

                                      Thank you for the continued support.

                                      In conclusion I will be selling my H90 because the poly pitch just doesn’t work as well as my Line 6 devices. I wanted it to replace my H9 but the ease of use of the editor on that pedal is so much better than the H90 control. This is of course preference but along with all the other issues a dealbreaker for me.

                                    • #189545
                                      stroboscapes
                                      Participant

                                        I tried giving it another shot before selling it but it blows my mind why there is no option to send a Midi CC to have it ON at 127 and OFF at 0, or at least like the H9 did have the option to assign one CC to ON and another to OFF. The only option is to toggle, so if I’m using a switcher I have to know exactly what sequence I’ll use to turn it on or off.

                                        Absolutely unusable

                                      • #189561
                                        stroboscapes
                                        Participant

                                          Then it doesn’t work with the firmware version 1.8.6. that allows additional values to be recognised by the device after a PC change.

                                          I tried sending 127 to “P Act/Byp” and it will change the state from say bypassed to active. Sending 127 on the same CC again bypasses it from active. I would expect by the manual that 0 would be bypass and 127 active, but 127 just toggles it. So there is no way to definitely send a value for Bypass.

                                          Using “P Act/Byp (M)” does the same but only activates it for a brief moment.

                                          • #189563
                                            tbskoglund
                                            Keymaster
                                            Eventide Staff

                                              This behavior has not changed throughout different firmware versions.

                                              What is the MIDI controller you are using? From what you describe, it sounds like your MIDI CCs are momentary; they send a high value when the footswitch is pressed and a low value when it is released.

                                              You need your MIDI controller to only send the specific high or low CC value, then it should work correctly for discrete active/bypass messages when using P Act/Byp (M).

                                          • #189564
                                            stroboscapes
                                            Participant

                                              In that case the other MIDI devices I have would have the same issue, but they don’t. I use a Strymon and a Line 6 device with the same EFX LE controller and none of them have the issue. All of them have the same CC logic where 127 is on and 0 is off.

                                              • #189565
                                                tbskoglund
                                                Keymaster
                                                Eventide Staff

                                                  I’m sorry, I don’t have any further information to provide.

                                                  As described above, you need to use  P Act/Byp (M) and you need your MIDI controller to only send the specific high or low CC value, then it should work correctly for discrete active/bypass messages when using P Act/Byp (M). Many users use the H90 with MIDI this way.

                                              • #189566
                                                stroboscapes
                                                Participant

                                                  That’s ok, I’m just stating the issues I was having in case someone else has reported the same issue. The same issue persists with the Tuner function, sending 127 activates the Tuner, sending 0 does nothing. I have to send 127 again for it to deactivate.

                                                • #189583
                                                  stroboscapes
                                                  Participant

                                                    Here’s another thing to add to a wishlist for future improvement: As of now, the H90 Control app does not provide a direct interface to set the tempo (BPM) for individual presets. Tempo adjustments are primarily managed through the H90 hardware itself.

                                                    This was doable in the H9 and surely people would want this.

                                                Viewing 16 reply threads
                                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.